How to Choose the Right Landing Net Size for Trout

Start With the Fish You Actually Catch

Most people shop for a net like they shop for a rod. They picture the biggest fish they have ever seen and buy for that day. I have watched it happen in the shop and at shows. A guy who fishes a creek full of 10 inch brook trout walks in wanting the biggest hoop I build. He is thinking about the 22 inch brown he saw once.

Buy the net for the fish you catch most weeks, not the fish you dream about. An oversized net snags every branch, catches the current, and gets heavy by the end of the day. A net that fits your fish lands them faster, which is better for the fish and better for your release.

Think in rough bands. Small water with small fish, say 6 to 14 inches, wants a smaller hoop. Medium rivers with fish in the 12 to 20 inch range want something in the middle. Big water with a real shot at fish over 20 inches wants a wide hoop and a deeper bag.

Match the Hoop to the Water

The hoop is the frame opening. My K1 runs a 12 inch hoop. It was built for tight water. Brushy creeks, small spring streams, the kind of places where you are ducking under tag alders and your net is strapped to your back all day. A 12 inch hoop disappears against your back and still swallows a 16 inch trout without folding it in half.

The K2 runs a 15 inch hoop. That is the do everything size. Driftless streams, medium tailwaters, most of what trout anglers fish most of the time. A 15 inch hoop handles a 20 inch fish fine.

Past that, you are talking custom. When a customer tells me they are fishing big western rivers or lake run fish, we size up. There is no hard rule, but a hoop under 13 inches lives on small water, 14 to 16 inches is the all around middle, and anything bigger is for big fish in big places.

One mistake I see a lot: buying the big net for small water. The hoop catches on everything behind you. You will leave it in the truck by July. The best net is the one you actually carry.

Handle Length Matters as Much as Hoop Size

Everyone obsesses over the hoop and ignores the handle. The handle is what does the work. On a small creek, a short handle is right. You are netting close to your feet, often with your rod tip high and the fish in fast current at your knees. A long handle on a small creek is just leverage working against you.

Wade deeper or fish from a boat and the math changes. Kneeling on the bank of a tailwater with a foot of bank between you and the water, you will wish for a few more inches of handle. In a drift boat, a longer handle is almost required. You are reaching over the gunwale while your buddy holds the oars.

My rule of thumb is simple. If your netting hand is usually within arm's reach of the fish, go short. If there is water, bank, or boat rail between you and the fish, go longer. When someone orders a custom net, the handle conversation takes longer than the hoop conversation.

Do Not Forget the Bag

Hoop size and bag depth are a team. A wide hoop with a shallow bag is a launch ramp. The fish hits the mesh and slides right out. A bag with real depth keeps a hot fish contained while you get your hemostats out.

For catch and release fishing, which is most of what my customers do, I tell people to think about cradling. The net should cradle the fish in water while you work the hook free. A bag deep enough to keep the fish wet and a hoop wide enough to hold it level.

The Carry Question

Be honest about how the net travels. If you hike three miles into a canyon, every ounce and every inch counts. A smaller net with a shorter handle, or a net with a lanyard ring you trust, gets carried. A net that is a pain to carry gets left in the truck, and the best net in the world does nothing from the back seat.

If you fish from a boat, size stops mattering for the carry. The net rides in a holder. Then size is only about the fish. If you wade and wear a vest or a sling pack, the net rides on your back or hangs from a magnet. That is where oversized nets punish you. They catch branches. They fill with wind. A 15 inch hoop is about the biggest thing I would want on my back on brushy water.

Weight matters too. My nets run about 30 ounces. That is super light for a hardwood net, and it is the difference between a net you carry all day and a net you leave in the truck. A big net with a deep bag and a long handle adds up, but at 30 ounces you forget it is on your back. My nets are steam bent hardwood with a tung oil base and about seven coats of Epifanes spar varnish, sanded between coats. That finish stands up to water season after season, and the care is simple: rinse and dry the net after a day on the river, and if the varnish ever wears thin, a light scuff with 220 grit and a fresh coat or two of spar varnish brings it back. But no finish fixes a net you hate carrying. Get the size right first.

When to Go Custom

Stock sizes cover most anglers. The K1 and K2 exist because they cover the two most common answers: small water and everything else. But sometimes the honest answer is neither.

Go custom when your water is specific. A spring creek regular who fishes one stretch of river knows exactly what he needs. If you can describe your average fish, your average water, and how you carry the net, a custom build gets you a net that fits like it was made for you. Because it was.

I will also build for an occasion. Engraving, a specific wood, a handle shaped for a hand that has trouble with a standard grip. That is the part of the shop I enjoy most. A production net is built for an average. A custom net is built for a person.

The Short Version

Size the net to the fish you catch most, the water you fish most, and the way you carry it. Small water and small fish: smaller hoop, shorter handle. Medium water: the middle sizes. Big water and big fish: go wide and deep. Handle length follows how far you reach. Bag depth follows how the fish fights. And when none of the stock answers fit your water, that is what a custom net is for.

Take a look at the shop at kinniforge.com. The K1, the K2, and the custom builds are all there. If you are not sure which size fits your water, reach out. I would rather talk you into the right net than sell you the wrong one.

Next
Next

What Steam-Bending Does to Wood (and Why It Matters)